RF Generation Message Board

Am I the only one here who thinks Gran Turismo is WAY overrated?  I mean, I know it has incredible detail, and the physics are very realistic, but so what?  I just don't have all that much fun playing it.  For me, it takes realism about ten steps too far, at the expense of a very important element of any video game: fun.  Spending hours and hours trying to accelerate around the same stupid curve just the right way so I can actually get to the races seems so pointless to me.  The game has some great elements, but I just think it's way overrated and at times downright irritating to play.

I'm not that fond of Gran Turismo, but I wouldn't call it too realistic. It's just an arcade racer. What bothers me is that you can't just race, but that you first have to get licenses, choose a car out of a possible 250, then buy crap to make that car faster, so you end up with a 1200 hp car. Then you have to attempt to race with that car through a circuit that was never ever meant for those speeds.  I prefer Sega GT. It has the same basic principle, but with a lot less crap and a lot more racing.

Exactly.  I guess what I meant by "too realistic" is that they try to make it so much of a simulation that they forget to make it a game.  Sega GT has enough customization and enough options to keep things interesting, but not so much that it gets in the way of gameplay.

I don't like it. You can't crash, where is the fun in that?

And this whole business with the licences. Hey, I bought the game with my money, so let me play it already! My driving technique in an actual race differ a great deal from that required to pass some of the licences.

I got majorly pissed off with GT3 on my PS2, because there were not enough sound options. I don't often need sound options, but I expect them to be there. I could not get a happy balance between game sound and background music, and it really irritated me.

I prefer such games as Penny Racers. In fact I thought Penny Racers was very good unlike the reviewers and unlocked just about everything. So I guess I'm not too fond of realism.

I'd say the racing game I've spent the most time with is probably Diddy Kong Racing, of all games.  I thought it was the best racer on N64, and it's probably one of my favorites all-time.  I know it's a completely different kind of game than Gran Turismo, but the simplicity of it makes it so much FUN.

I'm not a big fan of racing games in the first place, but I found that the fun of building up your car was brought down by the fact I couldn't do a picture perfect S-turn so I couldn't get my license.  What a completely retarded idea for a game.

My fave racing series has to be the Need For Speed games, and although Underground was a bit of a tangent/unconventional, I still enjoyed it as it was a damn fun game.  I like to think EA generally gets the balance between fun and realism pretty much spot on with NFS games.

If you are looking for a really good racing game, mike, take a look at Underground.  Unfortunately, it buys into the new import tuner/ricer fad, oh god i hope fad.  But it has the best racing engine I have ever played, and the graphics are amazing.  Although they use the same map for every race, you get very different courses.  (The whole game is set in the downtown area of Big American City.)  Its even great over lan.

Too bad all the cars in Gran Turismo drive about the same. The only difference of note is the Rally car; street car; and F1 car groups.

While playing an Initial D racing game in the arcade (I was in L.A. for the weekend) I had the chance to use an RX-7 in a driving game, which was simulated perfectly.  A few days later I went home and drove my real life RX-7 and had much more fun.  Since then, driving games are dead to me.

the best thing about Gran Turismo on the PS2 is in two player mode, driving in opposite directions for a head on crash, that's amusing for about 10 minutes.

that whole liscense thing put me off as well. one of the racing games I most enjoyed was Test Drive Offroad 2 for the PS1. very arcadey with hugely unrealistic jumps but it gives a good sensation of speed.

the number of available cars in the Gran Turismo series is cool, you just have to work tooo hard to get to any of them.

Grand Turismo IS overrated and it has horrible control. I'd rather play Rush 2 for N64 or even Rad Racer for the NES than that pile of trash.

another race game I really enjoy but has actually spoiled other race games for me is Pro Race Driver by Codemasters for the PS2.  The races are fun, there are plenty of cars and tracks and there is car damage. after playing through Pro Race Driver playing a racing game that does not have car damage bugs the snot out of me.

Let me guess you hate Sony? I have read a few of your post and all of them bash Sony.

Gran Gran Turismo hardly has terrible controls.

Or based on his sig he is a Nintendo "fanboy".

I have never played any one of the Gran Turismo games for more than 30 mins a piece.

I thought Gran Turismo 3 was pretty good what i did play of it.

Your a fanboy ::)  

I love Nintendo , but Gran Turismo is not a pile of crap. Gran Turismo 3 was an awesome game with a vast array of elements that were thoughtfully done. I have not played GT4 yet , but I know it will probably surpass GT3. Some people like realistic things in a game and if thats what your thing is then GT3 is for you.

I can tell you, I dont think GT4 will do as well as 3. Just a few weeks after its release it sits on our shelves and nobody is looking at it. I know this is just one store in a small town, but still, that's not a good sign. I think they did GT3 so well, that they can't outdo themselves and people are affriad it will be bad.

Thats a possiblity , but maybe people are just busy buying other stuff right now and they figure they can get GT 4 later for less  ;) I know I will wait for a price drop.

that's me as well. I've got so much to play it doesn't make sense to buy games when they are still full price. though I gotta admit I was nor aware it was out already.

I'm not a big fan of racing games.  I will admit that I do like the Mario Kart games.

I honestly hate racing games. Im more of an RPG gamer... and driving a car you save up your entire life for ; not to mention the cost of the hellish game itself, then you try to go for a curve in the first track of the racing game, and you crash head on at 260 MPH.. and your car it trashed and dead, you now have this irreversable opinion on the game, and once you manage to find the time to play the game again, and you crash.. again... and you lose..  ... it all dosent seem 'fun' to me. But in the GTA games... if you crash your car, i jump out, snipe another driver, take their car, crash it.. repeat. G.T. 4 needed a 'hijack' option. Because its such an over realistic game, and if I had just crashed my car, id take the next one I see.   Well, its only an opinion.
~Tyne

I like Racing games, but some reason I don't find Gran Turismo all that interesting. It almost seems all the same. Maybe because it is because I like futuristic racing games like F-Zero or Wipeout, or the wonderful Mario Kart series. I can spend my money on good "good games" like Donkey Kong: Jungle Beat instead of getting this game.