RPG Analysis

Posted on Mar 6th 2016 at 08:00:00 AM by (Fleach)
Posted under Review, The Count Lucanor, Indie, PC, Mac, Linux, Steam, 2D, Pixel Art, Bach Chiptunes

PC, Mac, Linux

The Count Lucanor, from Baroque Decay Games, is the result of blending The Legend of Zelda and survival horror. It's a combination that's intriguing enough to support the core gameplay, but its execution is only effective for a couple of hours.

The set up for The Count Lucanor is very reminiscent of a fairy tale or young children's adventure story. You play as Hans, a young boy who can't stand his life of poverty any longer. On his tenth birthday, he asks his mother if she has any presents for him. When Hans' mother says that she has nothing to give him, he proclaims that he's tired of being poor and jealous that the other kids can celebrate their birthdays in ways he can't. Hans is ten and has become a man, so he says, and with that, he leaves home in search of riches and adventure.

As Hans explores his rural village, he meets other townsfolk who are in some sort of dilemma that only Hans can solve by giving away items he received from his mother - items that might prove useful later. There's an elderly woman in need of a cane and a goatherd who forgot to pack a lunch. Whether the player decides to help these characters determines how they treat Hans in later events in the game. Eventually, the game will bring Hans to a small graveyard with a headstone that looks oddly familiar. A raven knocks Hans unconscious and when he awakens, things become very creepy.

The world Hans wakes up in is a dark, sinister place with rivers of blood and demonic goats. Naturally, Hans is frightened and decides to return home until he comes across a kobold who leads him to a mysterious castle. Once inside, the kobold tells Hans of the ageing Count who has no heirs to inherit his wealth and that he can claim these riches if he's able to guess the kobold's name. This is where the actual gameplay of The Count Lucanor begins.

Within the castle, Hans meets the villagers from earlier that day, but now they are dead or ill-tempered toward the boy. If you chose to help these characters, they will treat you more favorably and offer you valuable items or hints. Conversely, if you ignored them, they will make sure Hans remembers that he chose to be selfish. The castle itself consists of the courtyard containing the aforementioned NPCs and series of rooms containing the letters of the kobold's name. This is where the game fails to do something more engaging and thought-provoking. When I was told that I'd have to guess the kobold's name, I expected to piece together clues; instead, solving the puzzles in each room reveals a letter and I had to play what was essentially a game of Scrabble once the time came to solve the kobold's name. This could be due to the team's previous experience with , but it was disappointing for the climatic moment to be presented this way.

The main reason this let me down is because everything else in the game is actually quite good. Evil servants roam the castle and encountering one of them will more often than not result in a game over. Fortunately, Hans can hide under tables and behind curtains to avoid being seen. These stealth systems are very simple, but they effectively create tension in what would otherwise be a very dull experience. The puzzle rooms are also well done, but not very challenging. The pixel art and soundtrack redeemed The Count Lucanor, if only very slightly. The artwork is gorgeous and expressive. Monsters look terrifying and characters have fine detail, especially in the few cutscenes. Even the soundtrack, which is made up of short chiptune renditions of Bach, supports the game's setting and tone.

Unfortunately, all of this only contributed to a couple hours of interest. The ghostly whispers which fill the castle halls are faded into the background and the creatures became more of an obstacle than a threat.

Baroque Decay claims that the games is a four hour experience, but it only had my interest for a little over three. I'd be wrong to call The Count Lucanor a bad game, because it isn't. There's potential and many good ideas, and it's a decent attempt at survival horror from a 2-D perspective. In short, the sum of its parts is greater than the whole. However, the effort of the developer is very noticeable in the game, pulling off a 2-D survival horror isn't easy and I applaud the attempt. Despite some late game things that didn't work for me personally I would still recommend The Count Lucanor.

Permalink | Comments [6] | Digg This Article |

Recent Entries
Restoring a Nintendo Playchoice 10 Arcade in 2021 - Russ Restores EP 1 (5/9/2021)
Realizing A Game Collecting Dream (5/6/2021)
RF Cinema: Mortal Kombat (5/4/2021)
Shoot the Core-cast Episode 033 - Demonizer (4/27/2021)
Breath of Fire (4/25/2021)

Well written Floyd. Thanks for putting this one together.
Thanks Duke! And thanks for sending this my way. It was a decent game with some good ideas. Such a bummer that it kind of drops the ball later on.
Dude, you had me at The Legend of Zelda and survival horror, but I do have a question.  Going by what you experienced whilst playing the game, would you consider it a worthwhile experience overall, despite the problems you perceived with it?

Thanks, Floyd.  Great article.
@bombatomba: If there's anything I missed in this article it was a final decision on whether to recommend the game or not.

The effort of the developer is very noticeable in the game. Pulling off a 2D survival horror isn't easy and I applaud the attempt. Despite some late game things that didn't work for me personally I would still recommend The Count Lucanor.

You should probably edit that into the main body...

I was wondering that but since it isn't on "Xbox" it is highly unlikely i would be playing it either way :-/
Thanks for the write-up on this one.  I hadn't heard of it, but seeing as how it's maybe not my cup of tea, I won't go out of my way to snag it on Steam.

 Login or register to comment
It appears as though you are not a member of our site, or are not logged in.
It appears as though you can not comment currently. Becoming able to comment though is easy! All you need to do is register for the site! Not only will you be able to access any other site features including the forum and collection tools. If you are a registered user and just need to login then you can do so here.

Comment! It's easy, thoughtful, and who knows you might just enjoy it!
This is Fleach's Blog.
View Profile | RSS
Role Playing games are my favourite genre of the gaming library. I feel it is appropriate to take a look at the games that have touched me in my time as a gamer and collector and share them with the community. Feel free to discuss your thoughts, ideas, and challenge my opinions. The conversation is welcomed.
Blog Navigation
Browse Bloggers | My Blog
Hot Entries
Hot Community Entries
Site content Copyright © rfgeneration.com unless otherwise noted. Oh, and keep it on channel three.