@blcklblskt: Congrats! Those aren't easy to find.
It's been a while so here we go. I want to thank Crabby for his help with these:
My church recently had a rummage sale and I was able to grab these:
Amazon had a sale on Enloop kits so now I don't need to worry about batteries for all of these controllers:
I picked up some cases to make it easier to find the play copies of the Sega CD games (Thanks CoverProject!):
I picked up some more $2 Xbox 360 games:
I picked up some more $2 PS3 games:
These were $5 each:
I used the last Goodwill coupon I had to grab this for $7:
The Madden was stuck in the XBOX disc drive and the Disney Infinity playset was $3:
It looks like the same person who donated their Xbox donated these (The Akai Katana was part of my father's day gift):