If it's possible, I would try to test the system before buying it. You can't be too careful with CD-based systems. I would probably recommend using Craigslist, where you'll find deals every bit as good as at a yard sale, and most of the time the seller is more than willing to let you test the system first.*
*Of course, I am basing this on my usage of CL here in the Twin Cities. It's hard to quantify that "Minnesota nice" quality
I would definitely ask about trying it out at some places, but some of the houses we go to, I wouldn't feel safe going inside of.
I check our Craigslist twice daily, and haven't found a Xbox for under $200 yet. Though Youngstown's doesn't get a fraction of the traffic your's probably gets.